Replacing a Balance Staff (II)

By providing the watch's serial number, movement size, and balance pivot diameter, the parts supplier can provide the replacement staff (if you do not have the parts catalog to find the part number). Balance staffs come in all shapes and sizes:


Mount the hairspring side of the staff into a lathe collet that just fits onto it, and install the collet into the lathe:


Use a graver to remove the hub on the staff. This is a steel graver (a carbide graver is much better for this purpose):


I hold the graver against the t-rest with the diamond-shaped side of the graver facing upwards and at right angles to the surface of the metal to be cut. Do not remove the entire hub in order to avoid cutting into the balance arm itself, but leave a very small amount of hub that will easily break off like a small washer. Here is a balance staff (from another watch) with the remainder of the hub (the small "washer"):


The balance and staff are mounted onto a hole stump (part of the staking set) with the hairspring side facing down. A hole punch with rounded edges is mounted through the hole at the top of the stake and over the end of the staff pivot. A small amount of tapping with a one-ounce hammer and the balance staff should fall out easily.


Place the new staff into a hole in the staking block, where the hole just fits around the staff, with the small shoulder just above the staff hub facing upwards. Place the balance wheel onto this hub shoulder and stake the shoulder over the edge of the balance using a round-edged hole punch first, to spread the shoulder, and then a flat-faced hole punch to "fold" the edge of the shoulder over the balance.


You must check that the balance wheel on the new staff is true:



The roller table is installed under the balance wheel against the hub using the staking set. If the roller is a single roller, you must select a hole punch with a notch on the side for the roller jewel. This watch has a double roller, however. You must align the roller jewel with the marking you made on the balance wheel earlier. After staking on the roller table, you must check the poise (weight distribution) of the balance assembly, without the hairspring:


The poising tool must be absolutely level for this test. This poising tool has a bubble level built into it, which makes leveling it easy. If the balance wheel were out of poise, the heavier side would consistently rotate to the low side because of gravity. Weight could be added or removed by using timing washers or by undercutting one or more screws on the balance rim. Note that while you want to alter the weight distribution to poise the balance, you do not want to alter of overall weight of the balance or you would experience timekeeping problems.

Mount the hairspring onto the balance by pushing the hairspring collet onto the staff, using a flat-faced hole punch and the staking block (to keep the punch in a vertical position). The watch must be cleaned, repaired, assembled and lubricated prior to testing on the timing machine. Here is a photo of the watch with all the gears and other parts, but without the pillar plates, in order to show the gear train:

12 size Elgin

Please note that this essay is intended to introduce readers to a method for replacing a balance staff for a pocket watch or clock. This essay is not an adequate substitute for proper instruction from a qualified watchmaker. In other words, you could not go out and successfully replace a staff by just reading this essay: you must have appropriate instruction and guidance from an experienced watchmaker looking over your shoulder as you learn. There is no substitute for experience, just as there is no substitute for proper instruction.

Clock Repair Main Page
Escapements in Motion
Links Page